Toronto homeowners often learn about the 10% holdback only after a neighbour warns them about construction liens on a nearby job. House painting holdback Ontario rules come from the Construction Act, which sets how much you keep back from each payment and for how long. Get the timing right, and the holdback limits what you could owe if a subcontractor or paint supplier goes unpaid. This article is part of our house painting guide and covers the rules from the hiring side of the project. Since 1991, Home Painters Toronto has painted 20,000+ homes across Toronto and the GTA and earned 1,200+ positive reviews on HomeStars, Google and Houzz, so we hear these payment questions on almost every quote we write.
Under Ontario's Construction Act, you generally keep back 10% of each payment to a painter as the work is done. You release it once the 60-day lien period after completion has passed and no lien affects your property. If a lien is registered, the claimant has 90 more days to perfect it.
Key Takeaways
- The basic holdback is 10% of the value of work and materials supplied, under section 22 of the Construction Act.
- An unpaid supplier can preserve a lien within 60 days of completion, even after you pay the painter in full.
- Since January 1, 2026, an invoice can be deemed "proper" unless you flag problems in writing within 7 days.
- Our projects typically take 2 to 5 business days, per our project averages, so annual release rarely applies.
- Routine maintenance painting may fall outside lien rights, so get legal advice before you skip the holdback.
House Painting Holdback in Ontario: What It Is and Who It Protects
House painting holdback in Ontario is the 10% of each payment an owner keeps back to cover any trades or suppliers the painter fails to pay. Ontario's Construction Act requires every payer to retain 10% of the price of work and materials as they are supplied. The holdback is not a penalty or a sign of mistrust. It is a standard part of how construction payment works in this province.
The holdback protects two groups at the same time. Trades and suppliers who never dealt with you directly get a fund they can claim against. You, as the owner, get a ceiling on your liability. On a painting job, that chain can include the painting company, subcontracted crews and the paint store.
| Term | Plain-Language Meaning |
|---|---|
| Basic holdback | 10% of the value of work and materials supplied, kept by the owner (Construction Act, s. 22) |
| Lien | A claim an unpaid trade or supplier registers on your property title |
| Preserve | Register the lien on title, within 60 days of the triggering event |
| Perfect | Start a court action to keep the lien alive, within 90 more days |
| Proper invoice | An invoice that meets section 6.1 of the Act and starts the 28-day payment clock |
| Notice holdback | Extra money you keep after receiving a written notice of lien |
Does the Construction Act Cover a House Painting Job?
The Construction Act covers a house painting job when the work counts as an "improvement." The Act defines that as an alteration, an addition or a capital repair to the land. A capital repair is one meant to extend the normal economic life of a building or raise its value. The Act excludes maintenance done to prevent normal deterioration or keep a building in a normal, functional state. Painting sits right on that line.
Most homeowner articles say the holdback applies to every renovation. That is too simple for painting work. A whole-house exterior repaint with new fascia, caulking and primer looks like capital repair. A touch-up of scuffed hallway walls looks like maintenance. Ontario construction lawyers point out that there is no bright-line test, so close cases turn on their own facts.
Our advice is simple. Keep the holdback on any job with repairs or a full repaint, because holding it costs only a short wait. If you plan to skip it on a small job, speak with a lawyer first.
Capital Repair vs Maintenance: Where a Repaint Usually Lands
The scope in your exterior painting or interior painting quote is the best clue to how the Act treats the work. The table below shows how common jobs tend to line up. Treat it as a starting point for a conversation with your lawyer, not a ruling.
| Painting Scope | Likely Treatment | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Full exterior repaint with rotted fascia or siding replaced | Likely capital repair | New wood and coatings extend the life of the building envelope |
| Whole-house exterior brick staining | Possibly capital repair | A long-life coating that changes and protects the masonry face |
| Interior repaint after drywall repair | Possibly capital repair | Repairs restore damaged wall surfaces before the finish coats |
| Touch-ups on scuffed walls or trim | Likely maintenance | Keeps the home in a normal, functional state |
| Seasonal re-coat of a deck or fence | Likely maintenance | Prevents normal weathering of an existing finish |
How the 10% Holdback Works on a Painting Contract, Step by Step
The 10% holdback works by paying each invoice less 10% and keeping that money until the lien period ends. You release it once you confirm your title is clear. Follow these steps in order:
- Sign a contract that states the price, schedule and holdback, following the Consumer Protection Act rules for painting contracts.
- Receive a proper invoice for each payment stage, with the scope and amount clearly listed.
- Pay each invoice less 10%, and keep a running total of the amount held back.
- Record the completion date in writing once the punch list and final walkthrough are done.
- Wait out the 60-day preservation period that follows completion.
- Search your property title for registered liens and confirm you have no written notice of lien.
- Release the holdback promptly, since the Act treats release as mandatory once its conditions are met.
Settle one more detail before you sign. Ask whether the 10% applies to the price before or after tax, and record the answer in the contract. Our page on HST on house painting in Ontario explains how tax shows up on an invoice.
House Painting Holdback Amounts on Typical Toronto Jobs
House painting holdback amounts in Toronto run from about $40 on one room to $3,000 on a large exterior. The figures below apply 10% to our published project ranges. See the full breakdown in our guide to the cost of painting a house.
| Painting Job | HPT Price Range (Plus HST) | 10% Holdback Range |
|---|---|---|
| Bedroom repaint | $400 – $800 | $40 – $80 |
| Living or dining room | $400 – $900 | $40 – $90 |
| Trims, doors and baseboards | $700 – $1,200 | $70 – $120 |
| Small exterior | $2,000 – $4,000 | $200 – $400 |
| Medium exterior | $4,000 – $8,000 | $400 – $800 |
| Brick staining, medium to large | $6,000 – $10,000 | $600 – $1,000 |
| XL exterior | $12,000 – $30,000 | $1,200 – $3,000 |
Price ranges are Home Painters Toronto project averages. Holdback figures are 10% of those ranges, before HST.
A $40 holdback on a bedroom can feel pointless. Lien rights do not shrink with job size, though. Ontario lawyers note the Act has no blanket exemption based on project size. The bigger and more complex the job, the more parties are involved and the more the holdback matters.
How Long a Painter or Subcontractor Has to Register a Lien
A painter, subcontractor or supplier generally has 60 days to preserve a lien and 90 more days to perfect it, up to 150 days in total. Under section 31 of the Construction Act, the 60-day clock starts at the earliest of completion, abandonment or termination of the contract. A published certificate of substantial performance can also start it. For a subcontractor, it can also start on the last day they supplied work or materials. Perfecting a lien means starting a court action. A claimant who misses that step generally loses the lien.
| Event | Typical Timing | What the Owner Does |
|---|---|---|
| Contract signed | Before work starts | Confirm price, schedule and holdback in writing |
| Proper invoice received | Each payment stage | Flag any problem in writing within 7 days |
| Payment due | 28 days after a proper invoice | Pay 90%, or give notice of non-payment within 14 days |
| Work completed | Last day of contracted work | Record the completion date in writing |
| Lien preservation period | 60 days after completion | Keep the holdback and watch for notices |
| Title check | After day 60 | Search title and confirm no written notice of lien |
| Holdback release | Once the period ends and title is clear | Pay the 10% to the contractor |
| Lien perfection deadline | Up to 90 days after the preservation deadline | Only matters if someone registered a lien |
Why Touch-Ups Usually Don't Restart the Lien Clock
Touch-ups usually don't restart the lien clock because section 2(3) of the Construction Act deems a contract complete once little work remains. The test is remaining work worth no more than 1% of the contract price or $5,000, whichever is less. That means the 60 days can start before the very last brushstroke. Ontario courts have also held that fixing your own defective work generally does not extend a contractor's lien period. Write down the date the crew finished the contracted work, and keep it with your invoices. That one date anchors every deadline that follows.
Proper Invoices and Annual Holdback Release: The Latest Construction Act Changes
The latest Construction Act changes give owners 7 days to flag a deficient invoice in writing. They also make annual holdback release mandatory on contracts that run past one year. The Ontario Bar Association confirms that mandatory annual release of accrued holdback took effect on January 1, 2026. Here is what each rule means for a homeowner:
- 7 days to object: an invoice is deemed proper unless you flag what is missing in writing within 7 days.
- 28 days to pay: the Act's prompt payment rules require payment of a proper invoice within 28 days.
- 14 days to dispute: you can withhold all or part of a payment with a notice of non-payment within 14 days.
- Annual release: on longer projects, owners release accrued holdback each contract anniversary, after a notice and a 60-day lien window.
- Lien deadlines: the 60-day preservation and 90-day perfection periods did not change.
| Rule | Before the Amendments | Now |
|---|---|---|
| Deficient invoice | Owner could raise form problems later | Owner must object in writing within 7 days |
| Annual holdback release | Optional, only if the contract allowed it | Mandatory on contracts that run past one year |
| Lien deadlines | 60 days to preserve, 90 days to perfect | Unchanged |
For most homeowners hiring a painter, the 7-day rule matters far more than annual release. Our projects typically finish in 2 to 5 business days, based on our historical averages. They never reach a contract anniversary. Read each invoice the day it arrives. If a room, a colour or a line item is wrong, reply in writing that week.
Why a Lien Can Land on Your Home Even After You Pay the Painter
A lien can land on your home after you pay the painter in full because unpaid suppliers have lien rights against your property. Those rights exist even though you never hired the supplier. Picture a contractor who buys paint on account and then fails to pay the store. The store can preserve a lien on your title within the 60-day window. If you kept the 10% holdback, your exposure is generally capped at that amount.
A written notice of lien changes the math. After a written notice, the Act requires you to keep back the amount claimed, on top of the basic 10%. Paying that money out after the notice can leave you personally liable for it. The payment habits below are where most homeowners get caught.
| Payment Habit | What Can Go Wrong | Safer Option |
|---|---|---|
| Paying 100% on the last day | No fund left if a supplier registers a lien | Keep 10% until the lien period ends |
| Paying cash with no invoice | No record of what you paid or when | Pay by a traceable method against a proper invoice |
| Large deposit before work starts | You pay ahead of the value supplied | Keep the deposit modest and tied to the contract |
| Ignoring a written notice of lien | Personal liability for the noticed amount | Hold the noticed amount and get legal advice |
| Releasing holdback on a handshake | No proof that suppliers were paid | Get a written statement before release |
How to Pay a Painter Safely and Keep Your Title Lien-Free
You pay a painter safely by tying every payment to a written contract and a proper invoice. Keep the 10% holdback, and collect proof that suppliers were paid before you release it. The company you hire matters as much as the paperwork. Look for these signs before you sign:
- Own crews: a company with its own painters and carpenters has fewer subcontractors who could go unpaid. Learn the difference between an in-house crew and subcontractors.
- WSIB coverage: a WSIB-compliant contractor carries workers' compensation coverage for its crew. You can verify a WSIB clearance certificate before the start date.
- Itemized pricing: a detailed quote shows exactly what each payment covers. See what belongs in a painting estimate.
- Written warranty: clear terms in writing tell you how defects get fixed after the final payment. Our home painting warranty explained page sets out ours.
Documents to Collect Before You Release the Holdback
The documents to collect before releasing the holdback prove the work is complete and everyone was paid. Keep these together in one folder:
- The final invoice, marked as the last proper invoice for the job
- The written completion date, signed or emailed by the crew lead
- A written statement from the contractor that workers, subcontractors and suppliers are paid in full
- A title search, through ServiceOntario or your lawyer, showing no registered lien
- Copies of any written notices of lien and proof of how each was resolved
- A WSIB clearance certificate dated close to the completion date
Home Painters Toronto is WSIB compliant and fully insured with $5 million in general liability coverage. We put scope, colours and payment terms in writing before any paint is opened. Our warranties are lifetime on interior painting, 3 years on exterior, 15 years on brick staining and 5 years on cabinet spraying. You can read what homeowners say about our warranty-backed work in our client reviews.
Paying a Painter and Construction Liens: Homeowner FAQs
Yes, in most cases you should keep back 10% of each payment to a painter under Ontario's Construction Act. The holdback stays with you until the 60-day lien period after completion ends, and your title is clear. Keeping it limits what you could owe if a supplier or subcontractor goes unpaid.
Yes, a painter can register a lien on your house if they improved it and were not paid. The same right extends to subcontractors and suppliers who never signed a contract with you. The lien must be preserved within 60 days of the triggering event under the Construction Act.
A contractor generally has 60 days to preserve a lien in Ontario, usually counted from completion of the contract. After that, the claimant has 90 more days to perfect it by starting a court action. If either deadline passes, the lien generally expires.
Yes, holding back 10% is the safer choice even on a small painting job. Ontario lawyers note the Construction Act has no blanket exemption based on project size. Small touch-ups may count as maintenance, but that line is unclear, so legal advice beats guessing.
No, releasing the holdback early removes the protection it exists to provide. A finished-looking job tells you nothing about whether suppliers and subcontractors were paid. Wait until the 60-day period passes, then check your title before you pay the final 10%.
If the paint store wasn't paid, it can preserve a lien on your property within the 60-day window. If you kept the 10% holdback, your exposure is generally limited to that amount. If you also received a written notice of lien, keep back the amount claimed and speak with a lawyer.
Protecting Your Home: House Painting Holdback in Ontario
Protecting your home with house painting holdback in Ontario takes three habits: keep 10% back, record the completion date and check your title. Those steps cost nothing and turn a confusing statute into a simple routine. Read each invoice within 7 days, and keep every document in one place.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Rules and day counts can change, so confirm them on Ontario e-Laws or with an Ontario construction lawyer.
Brian Young founded Home Painters Toronto in 1991, building a family-run company that puts scope, colours and payment terms in writing before any paint is opened.
Want a painting contract with the scope, payment schedule and holdback spelled out before work starts? We offer fast, free quotes and warranty-backed work across Toronto and the GTA.
Contact Home Painters Toronto